SPEND $2000 OR MORE AND GET A FREE HANDGUN SAFE! + 15% OFF ACCESSORIES
Spend $2000 or more and get a free handgun safe!
Call Button
Speak With Expert
800-984-5719
Skip to content
Mesa Gun Safes vs Winchester Gun Safes: A Comparison

Mesa Gun Safes vs Winchester Gun Safes: A Comparison

Do you want one of the best American gun safes money can buy for your home or business?

You’ll notice one thing pretty quickly about high-end gun safes: they’re frequently made by American manufacturers. 

In America, making suitable gun safes requires professional craftsmanship, and this quality shows in their safes. If you’re looking for a tough gun safe for your home or business then you're in the right place.

In this guide, we’ll show you the Top 10 Best Gun Safes

You’ll discover:

  • The basics of what to look for in a gun safe
  • How to decide which gun safe is right for you
  • Our collection of the best gun safes
  • Recommendations on the best applications for each gun safe

Best of Mesa & Winchester Safes Compared

Criteria Mesa Safes Winchester Safes
Price

MBF Gun Safes Series (starting at around $600),

MGL Gun Safes Series (starting at around $500),

MGL14AS-E (around $1,000)

Legacy Premier Series (starting at around $1,000)

Bandit Series (starting at around $700)

Defender Series (starting at around $1,500)

RSC Rating

MBF Gun Safes Series and  MGL Gun Safes Series meet the RSC Attack Level 1 standard for residential security

Legacy Premier Series, Bandit Series, and Defender Series meet the RSC Attack Level 1 standard for residential security
Weight

MBF Gun Safes Series range from around 400 to 800 pounds

MGL Gun Safes Series range from around 300 to 600 pounds

 MGL14AS-E weighs around 350 pounds

Legacy Premier Series range from around 550 to 1,000 pounds

Bandit Series range from around 300 to 700 pounds

Defender Series range from around 600 to 1,000 pounds

Use Case

MBF Gun Safes Series, MGL Gun Safes Series and MGL14AS-E are suitable for residential and business use

Legacy Premier Series, Bandit Series, and Defender Series are suitable for home defense and tactical use
Additional Information MBF Gun Safes Series, MGL Gun Safes Series, and MGL14AS-E offer different sizes and capacities, electronic lock, and fire protection Legacy Premier Series, Bandit Series, and Defender Series

 

 

Mesa and Winchester gun safes are two of the most popular brands in the market. Both brands offer high-quality gun safes that are known for their durability and security features. While both brands have their own unique features and benefits, choosing the right gun safe can be a daunting task. In this article, we will compare Mesa and Winchester gun safes to help you make an informed decision.

Mesa gun safes are known for their all-steel construction, which makes them extremely durable. These safes are also equipped with fire-resistant features, making them ideal for storing guns and other valuable items. On the other hand, Winchester gun safes are known for their high-quality locks and security features. These safes are designed to keep your guns and other valuable items safe from theft and unauthorized access.

When it comes to choosing the right gun safe, there are several factors that you need to consider. These factors include the size of the safe, the type of lock, the level of fire protection, and the price. By comparing the features and benefits of Mesa and Winchester gun safes, you can make an informed decision that meets your specific needs and budget.

Key Takeaways

  • Mesa and Winchester gun safes are two of the most popular brands in the market.
  • Mesa gun safes are known for their all-steel construction and fire-resistant features, while Winchester gun safes are known for their high-quality locks and security features.
  • When choosing the right gun safe, it's important to consider factors such as size, lock type, fire protection, and price.

Overview of Mesa and Winchester Gun Safes

Mesa and Winchester are two popular manufacturers of gun safes. Both companies have a reputation for producing high-quality safes that are designed to protect firearms and other valuable items from theft and damage.

Mesa gun safes are known for their all-steel construction, which provides superior protection against theft and fire. They are available in a range of sizes and styles, from small safes that can hold a few handguns to large safes that can store dozens of rifles and shotguns. Mesa safes are also equipped with a range of security features, including electronic locks, pry-resistant doors, and drill-resistant hard plates.

Winchester gun safes are also well-regarded for their security features and durability. They are available in a range of sizes and styles, and can be customized to meet the needs of individual gun owners. Winchester safes are built with heavy-duty steel and feature pry-resistant doors, drill-resistant hard plates, and fire-resistant insulation.

When it comes to prices, Winchester gun safes can range from a few hundred dollars to several thousand dollars depending on the series and size. For example, the Winchester Ranger 42 Gun Safe has a capacity of 42 long guns and costs around $2,300. The Winchester Legacy Premier 26 Gun Safe, on the other hand, has a capacity of 26 long guns and costs around $1,200. Mesa gun safes are also available at a range of price points, with smaller models starting at around $500 and larger models costing several thousand dollars.

Overall, both Mesa and Winchester gun safes are excellent choices for gun owners who are looking for a high-quality safe to protect their firearms and other valuable items. The choice between the two will ultimately depend on individual preferences and needs.

Key Features of Mesa Gun Safes

Locking System in Mesa Safes

Mesa gun safes are equipped with a digital lock system which is highly secure and reliable. The locking system is designed to prevent unauthorized access to your firearms and valuables. The locking bolts are made of solid steel and are designed to withstand any attempted break-ins. Mesa gun safes also come with an auxiliary re-locker which is triggered in case of an attempted forced entry.

Fire Rating of Mesa Safes

Mesa gun safes are designed to provide superior fire protection. The MBF series of Mesa gun safes come with a fire rating of up to 2 hours. The fireboard used in the construction of these safes is designed to withstand high temperatures and prevent the internal temperature of the safe from rising. This ensures that your firearms and valuables are protected even in case of a fire.

Theft and Burglary Protection in Mesa Safes

Mesa gun safes are made of 12 gauge steel which is highly durable and resistant to break-ins. The locking bolts are made of solid steel and are designed to prevent any attempted forced entry. The MBF series of Mesa gun safes also come with a drill-resistant hard plate which is designed to prevent any attempts to drill through the safe. Mesa gun safes also come with a gun rack which provides additional protection and security to your firearms.

Mesa gun safes also come with a range of accessories such as dehumidifiers and lights which are designed to enhance the functionality of the safe. The MBF series of Mesa gun safes include models such as the MBF5922E, MBF6032E, and MBF7236E which are highly rated and provide superior protection and security to your firearms and valuables.

If you are looking for a gun safe with a range of features and superior protection, Mesa gun safes are a great choice.

Key Features of Winchester Gun Safes

Locking System in Winchester Safes

Winchester gun safes are equipped with advanced locking systems that provide maximum security to your firearms. Most of the safes come with a UL-listed S&G mechanical lock, which is considered to be one of the most secure locking systems in the industry. The locking bolts of Winchester safes are made of solid steel and are at least 1-inch in diameter. The Big Daddy series, for instance, has 1.5-inch locking bolts that provide extra protection against forced entry.

Fire Rating of Winchester Safes

Winchester gun safes are designed to protect your firearms from fire damage. Most of the safes come with a fire rating of at least 30 minutes at 1400°F. The Silverado 51, for example, has a fire rating of 2 hours at 1400°F. Winchester safes are constructed with fireboard and other fire-resistant materials that can withstand high temperatures and prevent the interior of the safe from reaching a temperature that can damage your firearms.

Theft and Burglary Protection in Winchester Safes

Winchester gun safes are built with high-quality materials that provide excellent protection against theft and burglary. The Legacy series, for instance, is made of 14-gauge steel and has a pry-resistant recessed door that provides extra security against forced entry. Winchester safes also come with a drill-resistant hard plate that protects the lock from being drilled out. Additionally, most of the safes have a triple-spoke handle that prevents the door from being pried open.

When it comes to accessories, Winchester gun safes come with a variety of options, including a gun rack, door panel organizer, and LED lighting. The Big Daddy series, for instance, has a door panel organizer that can hold up to 10 handguns and other small items. Winchester gun safes are available in different series, including the Win Big Daddy series, Silverado 51, and Legacy series. Prices for Winchester gun safes vary depending on the series and the size of the safe. A table of Winchester series and their range of cost is shown below:

Series Range of Cost
Big Daddy Series $2,000 - $4,500
Silverado 51 $2,500 - $4,000
Legacy Series $2000 - $3,500

Comparison of Mesa and Winchester Gun Safes

Locking System Comparison

When it comes to locking systems, both Mesa and Winchester offer a range of options. Mesa gun safes typically come with an electronic keypad lock or a combination lock, while Winchester gun safes offer electronic keypad locks, combination locks, and biometric locks. Both brands use locking bolts to secure the door, with Mesa typically using four or more and Winchester using between eight and ten.

Fire Rating Comparison

Fire protection is an important consideration when choosing a gun safe, and both Mesa and Winchester offer a range of fire-rated safes. Mesa gun safes are typically rated to withstand temperatures of up to 1750°F for up to an hour, while Winchester gun safes are rated to withstand temperatures of up to 1400°F for up to an hour.

Theft and Burglary Protection Comparison

Both Mesa and Winchester gun safes offer a range of features to protect against theft and burglary. Mesa gun safes typically feature a 10-gauge steel body and a 1-inch steel plate door, while Winchester gun safes feature a 12-gauge steel body and a 1-inch steel composite door. Mesa gun safes also come with drill-resistant hard plate and spring-loaded re-locker, while Winchester gun safes come with a drill-resistant hard plate, auxiliary re-locker, and pry-resistant recessed door.

In terms of warranty, Mesa offers a limited lifetime warranty on their safes, while Winchester offers a limited lifetime warranty on their gun safes as well.

When it comes to prices, the Winchester gun safes range from around $500 to over $3000 depending on the series, while Mesa gun safes range from around $700 to over $4000 depending on the size and features.

Overall, both Mesa and Winchester gun safes offer a range of features and options to suit different needs and budgets. It's important to consider factors such as fire rating, theft and burglary protection, and locking system when choosing a gun safe.

Choosing the Right Gun Safe

When it comes to choosing the right gun safe, there are several factors to consider. First and foremost, you want to make sure that the safe is secure and provides adequate protection for your firearms and other valuables.

One important feature to look for is a high fire rating. This will ensure that your firearms are protected in the event of a fire. You should also consider the safe's theft protection features, including the locking system and locking bolts.

Another important consideration is the size of the safe. You want to make sure that it is large enough to accommodate all of your firearms, as well as any other valuables you may want to store. Additionally, you should consider whether you want a gun rack or other accessories included with the safe.

When it comes to pricing, Mesa gun safes and Winchester gun safes both offer a range of options to fit any budget. However, it's important to note that online pricing may differ from in-store pricing, and you should always compare prices from authorized dealers.

In terms of warranty, both Mesa and Winchester offer warranties on their gun safes. However, it's important to read the fine print and make sure you understand what is covered and for how long.

Finally, if you have children in the home, you may want to consider a hidden gun safe or a safe with anchor holes to secure it to the floor or wall. This will help prevent accidental harm to your children or unauthorized access by intruders or thieves.

Overall, choosing the right gun safe requires careful consideration of your specific needs and budget. By doing your research and comparing features and pricing, you can find a quality gun safe that will provide the protection and peace of mind you need as a responsible gun owner.

Conclusion

After comparing Mesa gun safes and Winchester gun safes, it is clear that both brands offer high-quality and secure safes for gun owners. The decision between the two brands ultimately comes down to personal preference and specific needs.

Mesa safes are known for their durable construction and high-quality materials. They offer a range of sizes and styles to fit different needs and budgets. Mesa safes are also fire-resistant and provide excellent protection against theft and burglary.

Winchester safes, on the other hand, are known for their excellent fire protection capabilities. They offer a range of sizes and styles to fit different needs and budgets. Winchester safes also come with a limited lifetime warranty, which provides peace of mind to gun owners.

When it comes to price, both Mesa and Winchester safes offer a range of options to fit different budgets. However, it is important to note that Winchester safes tend to be more expensive than Mesa safes. For example, the Winchester Silverado series can range from $1,500 to $3,000, while the Mesa MBF gun safe series can range from $800 to $2,000.

Overall, both Mesa and Winchester offer high-quality and secure gun safes for gun owners. The decision between the two brands ultimately comes down to personal preference and specific needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Mesa gun safes more durable than Winchester gun safes?

Both Mesa and Winchester gun safes are made with high-quality materials and construction methods. However, Mesa gun safes are known for their durability and strength. Mesa uses thicker steel in their safes and offers a lifetime warranty on their products. Winchester also offers a good level of durability, but their safes may not be as robust as Mesa's.

What are the differences between Mesa gun safes and Winchester gun safes?

Mesa and Winchester gun safes differ in several ways. Mesa safes are generally heavier than Winchester safes, have thicker steel walls, and offer more customization options. Winchester safes, on the other hand, are often more affordable and offer a wider range of sizes and models.

Which brand offers better fire protection: Mesa or Winchester?

Both Mesa and Winchester gun safes are designed to protect against fire damage. However, Mesa gun safes are known for their superior fire protection. Mesa uses a proprietary blend of insulation materials that can withstand temperatures up to 1750 degrees Fahrenheit for up to two hours. Winchester safes also offer good fire protection, but may not be as effective as Mesa's.

What is the warranty for Mesa gun safes compared to Winchester gun safes?

Mesa gun safes come with a lifetime warranty, which covers defects in materials and workmanship. Winchester gun safes come with a limited warranty, which covers defects in materials and workmanship for a specified period of time. The exact length of the warranty varies depending on the model of the safe.

Do Mesa gun safes have better security features than Winchester gun safes?

Both Mesa and Winchester gun safes offer a range of security features, including electronic locks, pry-resistant doors, and reinforced steel walls. Mesa gun safes, however, are known for their advanced security features, such as drill-resistant hard plates and active locking bolts. Winchester safes also offer good security, but may not be as advanced as Mesa's.

Are Mesa gun safes worth the extra cost compared to Winchester gun safes?

Mesa gun safes are generally more expensive than Winchester safes. However, Mesa safes offer superior durability, fire protection, and security features. If you are looking for a high-quality gun safe that will protect your firearms and valuables for years to come, a Mesa safe may be worth the extra cost.

Previous article Liberty Safes Website: The Ultimate Solution for Your Valuables Security