SPEND $2000 OR MORE AND GET A FREE HANDGUN SAFE! + 15% OFF ACCESSORIES
Spend $2000 or more and get a free handgun safe!
Call Button
Speak With Expert
800-984-5719
Skip to content

Liberty vs Winchester Gun Safes 2015: A Comparison

Do you want one of the best American gun safes money can buy for your home or business?

You’ll notice one thing pretty quickly about high-end gun safes: they’re frequently made by American manufacturers. 

In America, making suitable gun safes requires professional craftsmanship, and this quality shows in their safes. If you’re looking for a tough gun safe for your home or business then you're in the right place.

In this guide, we’ll show you the Top 10 Best Gun Safes

You’ll discover:

  • The basics of what to look for in a gun safe
  • How to decide which gun safe is right for you
  • Our collection of the best gun safes
  • Recommendations on the best applications for each safe

 

Liberty and Winchester are two of the most popular brands of gun safes available in the market today. Both brands offer a wide range of models and lines, each with its own set of features and benefits. Choosing between the two can be a difficult decision, as both brands have their own strengths and weaknesses.

When comparing Liberty and Winchester gun safes, it is important to consider several factors, including security features, fire protection, size and capacity, construction and durability, models and lines, budget and value, additional features, theft protection, consumer reviews, and frequently asked questions. By taking these factors into account, you can make an informed decision and choose the gun safe that best meets your needs and preferences.

Key Takeaways

  • When choosing between Liberty and Winchester gun safes, it is important to consider factors such as security features, fire protection, size and capacity, construction and durability, models and lines, budget and value, additional features, theft protection, consumer reviews, and frequently asked questions.
  • Both brands offer a wide range of models and lines, each with its own set of features and benefits.
  • By taking the time to research and compare the different options available, you can find the gun safe that best meets your needs and provides you with the peace of mind you need to keep your firearms and other valuables secure.

Liberty vs Winchester: An Overview

When it comes to gun safes, two of the most popular manufacturers are Liberty and Winchester. Both brands are known for their quality and reliability, but there are some key differences between the two that are worth exploring.

One of the main differences between Liberty and Winchester gun safes is the level of security they offer. Both brands offer a range of safes with varying levels of security, but Liberty is generally considered to be the more secure of the two. Liberty's safes feature thicker steel walls and doors, as well as more locking bolts than Winchester's safes.

Another important factor to consider when comparing Liberty and Winchester gun safes is the price. While both brands offer safes at a range of price points, Winchester's safes tend to be more affordable than Liberty's. To give you an idea of the price difference, here's a table comparing the cost of some popular Winchester series:

Winchester Series Price Range
Bandit $500-$1,000
Defender $700-$1,300
Legacy $900-$1,600
Silverado $1,200-$2,500

It's worth noting that Liberty's safes are generally more expensive than Winchester's, but they also offer more advanced security features.

When it comes to the overall quality of the safes, both Liberty and Winchester are known for producing high-quality products. However, some gun owners prefer one brand over the other based on personal preference or experience.

Ultimately, the decision between a Liberty or Winchester gun safe comes down to your personal needs and preferences. If you're looking for the most secure option and are willing to pay a premium, Liberty may be the way to go. If you're on a tighter budget but still want a reliable and sturdy safe, Winchester is a great choice.

Security Features

When it comes to gun safes, security is a top priority. Both Winchester and Liberty offer safes with various security features to protect your firearms from theft or unauthorized access.

Lock Types

One of the most important aspects of a gun safe's security is the lock type. Winchester and Liberty offer both combination and electronic (keypad) locks. Combination locks are the traditional type of lock that require a sequence of numbers or letters to be entered in order to open the safe. Electronic locks, on the other hand, use a keypad that requires a code to be entered.

Door and Locking Bolts

The door and locking bolts are also important components of a gun safe's security. Both Winchester and Liberty offer safes with reinforced doors and multiple locking bolts. The number of locking bolts varies depending on the size and model of the safe.

Locking Mechanisms

In addition to the lock type, the locking mechanism is another important feature to consider. Winchester and Liberty both offer safes with reliable locking mechanisms that are designed to resist brute force attacks.

B-Rate Safe

A B-rate safe is a type of safe that has been certified by the Underwriters Laboratories (UL) as meeting certain standards for burglary resistance. Both Winchester and Liberty offer B-rate safes that are designed to provide maximum protection against theft.

Prices

When it comes to prices, Winchester and Liberty offer safes at different price points. For example, the Winchester TS-22 gun safe is priced at around $600, while the Liberty Fatboy gun safe is priced at around $2,500. It's important to consider your budget when choosing a gun safe, but don't sacrifice security for a lower price.

Overall, both Winchester and Liberty offer high-quality gun safes with reliable security features. When choosing between the two, consider your specific needs and budget to find the best option for you.

Fire Protection

When it comes to gun safes, fire protection is a crucial factor to consider. Both Liberty and Winchester safes are known for their excellent fire protection capabilities.

Liberty Safe, for example, offers safes with up to 2.5 hours of fire protection. Their safes are built from 7-gauge steel, with up to eighteen ½" thick, military-style locking bars for unbeatable security. The internal temperature of their safes is maintained below 350°F in a 1,200°F fire for up to 2.5 hours.

Winchester safes, on the other hand, maintain an internal temperature below 350°F in a 1,300°F fire for around an hour. Their safes also feature heat-activated seals that expand when heated, helping to keep smoke and heat at bay during fires.

Both brands offer safes that are UL-listed for fire protection, meaning they have been tested and certified to withstand specific levels of heat and time. It is important to note that fire ratings can vary depending on the size and model of the safe.

When comparing fire protection between Liberty and Winchester safes, it is important to consider the specific model and size of the safe, as well as the UL rating.

Overall, both Liberty and Winchester offer reliable fire protection for your firearms. It is important to choose a safe with a UL-listed fire rating that meets your specific needs and budget.

In terms of pricing, Winchester safes range from around $500 for their entry-level models to over $5,000 for their top-of-the-line safes. Liberty safes range from around $800 for their entry-level models to over $10,000 for their high-end safes. It is important to note that pricing can vary depending on the size, features, and level of fire protection of the safe.

In conclusion, both Liberty and Winchester offer high-quality safes with excellent fire protection capabilities. When choosing a safe, it is important to consider the specific needs of your firearms and choose a safe with a UL-listed fire rating that meets those needs.

Size and Capacity

When it comes to purchasing a gun safe, size and capacity are important factors to consider. Liberty and Winchester offer a variety of options to meet the needs of gun owners with different collections and storage requirements.

Liberty gun safes come in a range of sizes, from compact handgun safes to large gun vaults that can hold dozens of long guns. The company's largest safe, the Presidential 50, has a capacity of up to 41 long guns, while the smallest safe, the HD-50 Key Vault, can hold a single handgun. Liberty also offers a range of mid-size safes, such as the Colonial 50 and Fatboy Jr., which can hold between 25 and 48 long guns.

Winchester gun safes also come in a variety of sizes, from small handgun safes to large gun lockers that can hold multiple long guns. The company's largest safe, the Legacy 53, has a capacity of up to 51 long guns, while the smallest safe, the Home Defender, can hold a single handgun. Winchester also offers a range of mid-size safes, such as the Ranger 26 and Silverado 33, which can hold between 24 and 36 long guns.

When choosing a gun safe, it's important to consider not only the number of guns you have but also the size and type of guns. For example, long guns such as rifles and shotguns take up more space than handguns and may require a larger safe. Additionally, some gun owners may want to store other valuable items, such as documents or jewelry, in their safe, which can also affect the size and capacity needed.

It's also important to consider the location of the safe and whether it will fit in the desired space. Some gun safes are designed to fit in a closet or under a bed, while others are meant to be freestanding. Vehicle gun safes are also available for those who need to transport their firearms securely.

When it comes to prices, Winchester safes tend to be more affordable than Liberty safes. For example, the Winchester Defender 24-gun safe can be purchased for around $700, while the Liberty Colonial 50-gun safe starts at around $2,000. However, prices can vary depending on the series and features of the safe.

In conclusion, when choosing between Liberty and Winchester gun safes, it's important to consider the size and capacity needed for your gun collection and storage requirements. Both companies offer a range of options to meet the needs of gun owners, and prices can vary depending on the series and features of the safe.

Construction and Durability

When it comes to gun safes, construction and durability are two of the most important factors to consider. Both Liberty and Winchester offer high-quality safes with solid construction and durability.

Liberty safes are constructed using plate steel for the body and steel for the door frame. The door is made of composite steel and includes a fire seal for added protection. The body construction includes continuous welds for added strength and durability. Liberty safes also feature a dual relock system for added security.

Winchester safes, on the other hand, feature a steel body construction with a 14 gauge steel door. The door frame is reinforced with steel for added strength. Winchester safes are also fire-rated and include a heat-activated door seal for added protection.

In terms of durability, both Liberty and Winchester safes are built to last. Liberty safes are designed to withstand high-impact forces, while Winchester safes are constructed using concrete for added durability.

When it comes to pricing, Winchester offers a range of safes at different price points. For example, the Western series ranges from $599 to $1,099, while the Legacy series ranges from $1,799 to $2,299. Liberty safes, on the other hand, tend to be more expensive, with prices ranging from $1,000 to $5,000 or more.

Overall, both Liberty and Winchester offer high-quality gun safes with solid construction and durability. The choice between the two ultimately comes down to personal preference and budget.

Models and Lines

When it comes to gun safes, both Winchester and Liberty offer a range of models and lines to choose from. Let's take a closer look at what each brand has to offer.

Liberty Safe

Liberty Safe offers a wide range of models and lines, including the USA Series, Colonial Series, Fatboy Series, and more. Each series offers varying levels of fire protection and security features, with options to fit any budget.

The Colonial Series is one of Liberty's most popular lines, offering excellent security features at an affordable price point. The Colonial line includes models with a capacity ranging from 25 to 50 guns, and features a 60-minute fire rating and 4-inch military-style locking bars.

Winchester

Winchester also offers a variety of models and lines, including the Ranger Series, Legacy Series, and Treasury Series. Each series offers varying levels of fire protection and security features, with options to fit any budget.

One of Winchester's most popular lines is the Treasury Series, which features a 2.5-hour fire rating and a UL RSC security rating. The Treasury line includes models with a capacity ranging from 26 to 50 guns, and features a pry-resistant recessed door and a drill-resistant hard plate.

Price Comparison

If you're looking for a gun safe on a budget, it's worth noting that the Liberty Colonial Series is generally more affordable than Winchester's Treasury Series. Here's a quick breakdown of the price ranges for each line:

Liberty Colonial Series Winchester Treasury Series
$1,400 - $2,800 $2,500 - $5,000

Keep in mind that these prices are just a general range, and may vary depending on the specific model and features you choose.

Overall, both Liberty and Winchester offer a range of models and lines to choose from, with varying levels of fire protection and security features. It's important to carefully consider your needs and budget when selecting a gun safe, and to choose a reputable brand with a proven track record of quality and reliability.

Budget and Value

When it comes to gun safes, budget and value are important factors to consider. Both Winchester and Liberty offer a range of safes at different price points, making it possible for gun owners to find a safe that fits their budget.

For those on a tight budget, the Barska Quick Access Biometric Safe is a great option. It offers reliable entry systems and multiple entry mechanisms, all at an affordable price point. However, for those looking for a more substantial and secure safe, both Winchester and Liberty offer a range of options.

In terms of budget, Winchester's series of gun safes range in price from around $500 to $2,500. The Ranger series is the most affordable, while the Legacy series is the most expensive. Liberty's series of gun safes start at around $800 and go up to $5,000. The Centurion series is the most affordable, while the Presidential series is the most expensive.

When it comes to finding the best gun safe for your budget, it's important to consider factors beyond just price. Both Winchester and Liberty offer a range of features and benefits, such as fire protection, locking mechanisms, and interior organization. It's important to weigh these factors against your budget to find the best value for your money.

While Winchester and Liberty are popular choices for gun safes, there are also alternatives to consider. Some other budget-friendly options include the Stack-On Total Defense Gun Safe and the Steelwater Heavy Duty 16 Long Gun Safe. These safes offer a range of features at an affordable price point, making them a great option for those on a tight budget.

Overall, when it comes to budget and value, both Winchester and Liberty offer a range of options to fit different budgets and needs. It's important to carefully consider factors beyond just price to find the best gun safe for your collection.

Additional Features

When it comes to additional features, both Winchester and Liberty offer a variety of options to customize your gun safe to fit your specific needs. Here are some of the features to consider:

  • Dehumidifier: A dehumidifier can help prevent moisture buildup inside the safe, which can cause rust and damage to firearms. Both Winchester and Liberty offer dehumidifiers as an optional accessory.

  • Insurance: Some insurance companies offer discounts for gun owners who have a safe to store their firearms. Check with your insurance provider to see if this is an option for you.

  • Home Safe: If you're looking for a smaller safe to store a few firearms or other valuables, Winchester and Liberty both offer home safes that are more compact than their larger gun safes.

  • Vault Door: If you're building a safe room or vault, both Winchester and Liberty offer vault doors that can be installed to provide extra security.

  • Flexible Interior: Both brands offer flexible interior configurations, allowing you to customize the layout of your safe to fit your specific needs.

  • Anchor Holes: Anchor holes can be used to secure the safe to the floor or wall, adding an extra layer of security.

  • Underwriters Laboratories: Both Winchester and Liberty gun safes are UL-listed for security and fire protection.

  • Customizable: Many of the features mentioned above, such as interior configurations and anchor holes, can be customized to fit your specific needs.

  • S&G Mechanical Lock: Liberty offers a top-lit digital SecuRam lock, or you can choose an S&G mechanical lock.

When it comes to pros and cons, both Winchester and Liberty have their strengths and weaknesses. Winchester gun safes are generally more affordable than Liberty safes, but they may not offer the same level of customization and security features. Liberty gun safes are known for their durability and security, but they can be more expensive.

Overall, both Winchester and Liberty offer a range of gun safes to fit the needs of gun owners, from home safes to commercial safes. Whether you're looking for a hidden gun safe or a customizable interior, both brands have options to fit your specific needs.

Theft Protection

When it comes to gun safes, one of the most important factors to consider is theft protection. After all, the primary purpose of a gun safe is to keep your firearms secure and out of the wrong hands.

Both Liberty and Winchester offer a range of safes with varying levels of theft protection. One of the most important factors to consider is the safe's UL rating. UL, or Underwriters Laboratories, is an independent safety consulting and certification company that provides ratings for safes based on their ability to withstand various types of attacks.

Winchester safes typically provide UL Residential Security Container (RSC) ratings, while some Liberty safes are available with higher UL ratings, such as the TL-30 and TL-15, indicating enhanced burglary protection.

Another important factor to consider is the locking mechanism. Both Liberty and Winchester safes come with various locking mechanisms to suit individual preferences. Some of the most common locking mechanisms include electronic locks, combination locks, and key locks.

It's also important to consider the construction of the safe itself. A well-built safe will be more resistant to pry bars and other tools that burglars may use to gain entry. Both Liberty and Winchester offer safes with thick steel walls and doors that are designed to withstand attacks.

Ultimately, the level of theft protection you need will depend on your individual circumstances. If you live in an area with a high crime rate or have valuable firearms that you want to protect, you may want to invest in a higher-rated safe with a more robust locking mechanism and construction.

If you're looking for a safe that offers a good balance of security and affordability, it's worth considering the Winchester series. The series includes a range of safes at different price points, with the most affordable options starting at around $500 and the most expensive models costing upwards of $2,000.

Overall, whether you choose a Liberty or Winchester safe, make sure to select a model that provides the level of theft protection you need to keep your firearms secure.

Consumer Reviews

When it comes to choosing between Liberty and Winchester gun safes, consumer reviews can be a valuable resource. Many gun owners have shared their experiences with both brands online, providing insights into the pros and cons of each.

Overall, both Liberty and Winchester receive positive reviews from consumers. Many gun owners appreciate the durability and security of these safes, as well as the peace of mind they provide. However, there are some differences between the two brands that may be worth considering.

One factor that some consumers mention in their reviews is the price. While both Liberty and Winchester offer a range of safes at different price points, some consumers feel that Liberty safes are generally more expensive. Others note that Winchester safes can be a bit more affordable, particularly at the lower end of the price range.

Another consideration is the quality of the locks. Some consumers have reported issues with the locks on their Liberty safes, while others have had no problems. Winchester safes, on the other hand, are often praised for their high-quality locks and overall security.

Finally, some consumers have noted that Liberty safes tend to be heavier than Winchester safes, which can make them more difficult to move. However, this extra weight can also be seen as a positive, as it makes the safes more difficult to steal.

Overall, consumer reviews suggest that both Liberty and Winchester gun safes are high-quality options for gun owners. While there are some differences between the two brands, the right choice will depend on your individual needs and preferences.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Winchester safes reliable?

Winchester safes have been in the market for a long time and have a reputation for being reliable. However, some users have reported issues with the quality of the locking mechanism and the overall build quality of the safe. It is recommended to research and read reviews before purchasing a Winchester safe to ensure that it meets your needs.

What are the differences between Liberty and Winchester safes?

Both Liberty and Winchester safes are well-known brands in the gun safe industry. The main differences between the two brands are the quality of the materials used, the level of fire protection, and the locking mechanism. Liberty safes are known for their thicker steel walls and more advanced locking mechanisms, while Winchester safes are known for their affordability and wide range of sizes.

Are Steelwater safes better than Liberty safes?

Steelwater safes are known for their affordability and high-quality construction. However, when compared to Liberty safes, they fall short in terms of fire protection and overall build quality. Liberty safes are a more premium brand and are known for their advanced locking mechanisms, thicker steel walls, and better fire protection.

What sets Superior safes apart from Liberty safes?

Superior safes are known for their high-quality construction and advanced locking mechanisms. They are also known for their superior fire protection and are a popular choice for those who live in areas prone to wildfires. However, when compared to Liberty safes, they fall short in terms of affordability and range of sizes.

Which is the best gun safe brand?

The best gun safe brand will depend on your specific needs and budget. Liberty, Superior, and Steelwater are all well-known brands in the gun safe industry and offer a range of options for different budgets and needs. It is recommended to research and read reviews before purchasing a gun safe to ensure that it meets your requirements.

What are some gun safe brands to avoid?

There are some gun safe brands that are known for their poor quality and lack of security. It is recommended to avoid brands such as Stack-On, Bulldog, and Homak. These brands are known for their affordability, but they fall short in terms of security and fire protection.

Winchester Series Cost Range
Bandit Series $600 - $1,000
Treasury Series $1,000 - $2,000
Legacy Series $2,000 - $3,000
Silverado Series $3,000 - $5,000
Big Daddy Series $5,000 - $7,000
Defender Series $7,000 - $10,000
Previous article Liberty Safes Website: The Ultimate Solution for Your Valuables Security