SPEND $2000 OR MORE AND GET A FREE HANDGUN SAFE! + 15% OFF ACCESSORIES
Spend $2000 or more and get a free handgun safe!
Call Button
Speak With Expert
800-984-5719
Skip to content
American Security Safes vs Liberty Safes

American Security Safes vs Liberty Safes

Do you want one of the best American gun safes money can buy for your home or business?

You’ll notice one thing pretty quickly about high-end gun safes: they’re frequently made by American manufacturers.

In America, making suitable gun safes requires professional craftsmanship, and this quality shows in their safes. If you’re looking for a tough gun safe for your home or business then you're in the right place.

In this guide, we’ll show you the Top 10 Best Gun Safes

You’ll discover:

  • The basics of what to look for in a gun safe
  • How to decide which gun safe is right for you
  • Our collection of the best gun safes
  • Recommendations on the best applications for each safes 
Category American Security Safes Liberty Safes
Price The BFX Gun Safe from American Security is priced at around $2,500, while the BF7240 is priced at around $4,000. The Colonial 50 is priced at around $1,800, while the Presidential 50 is priced at around $6,000.
RSC The BFX Gun Safe from American Security is UL-certified RSC Level I burglary protection. The Colonial 50 is UL-certified RSC Level I burglary protection.
Weight The BFX Gun Safe from American Security weighs around 1,400 pounds, while the BFx7240 weighs around 1,500 pounds. The Colonial 50 weighs around 760 pounds, while the Presidential 50 weighs around 1,000 pounds.
Use Case American Security safes are great for those who need a high level of security for their firearms, and are willing to pay a higher price for it. Liberty safes are great for those who want a balance between security and affordability.
Brand Reputation American Security is a well-known and reputable brand in the gun safe industry, with a history dating back to 1949. Liberty is also a well-known and reputable brand in the gun safe industry, with a history dating back to 1988.
Customer Reviews American Security safes generally receive positive reviews for their high level of security and durability. Liberty safes also generally receive positive reviews for their balance between security and

 

When it comes to securing your valuables, only the best will do. As an avid outdoorsman and successful businessman, you demand quality and reliability in everything you purchase - including home security. With prized possessions like hunting gear, documents, firearms and heirlooms worth protecting, finding the right safe is essential for maintaining peace of mind.

As someone who values self-reliance, hard work and independence, you're selective about the brands you trust. American Security and Liberty Safes are two industry leaders often considered by serious security enthusiasts. Both have strong reputations among gun owners and preppers alike for durable, high-capacity safes.

However, with budgets, needs and priorities all varying, determining the best option can be challenging. As a discerning consumer, you want to feel confident your choice maximizes security, value and space. This in-depth comparison of American Security and Liberty aims to provide the insights needed to make an informed decision tailored to your standards.

We'll examine pricing, features, capacity, shipping and warranty coverage - weighing the pros and cons of each brand from the perspective of a self-reliant man seeking optimal protection. By the end, you'll have a clear understanding of which safe aligns best with priorities like eliminating worries through superior security, quality and bang for your buck.


American Security Safes Overview

American Security Safes depository safe closed

If you're looking for a high-quality safe to keep your valuables secure, American Security Safes is a great option to consider. American Security Safes, also known as AMSEC, is a U.S.-built safe manufacturer that offers a wide range of safes for different purposes, including gun safes and home safes.

One of the primary benefits of American Security Safes is their commitment to quality. They use thick steel and advanced locking mechanisms to ensure that their safes are as secure as possible. Additionally, their safes are designed to withstand fire and other potential hazards, so you can be confident that your valuables will be protected in the event of an emergency.

Another benefit of American Security Safes is their wide range of options. They offer safes in different sizes and with different features, so you can choose the one that best suits your needs and budget. Whether you're looking for a small safe to store important documents or a large gun safe to protect your firearms collection, American Security Safes has a safe that will work for you.

Overall, if you're looking for a high-quality safe that you can trust to keep your valuables secure, American Security Safes is definitely worth considering. With their commitment to quality and wide range of options, you're sure to find a safe that meets your needs and exceeds your expectations.

Related Posts:

Liberty Safes Overview

Liberty safe Centurion 24

If you are in the market for a high-quality safe to protect your valuable possessions, then Liberty Safes are definitely worth considering. Liberty Safes are made by one of the top U.S.-built safe manufacturers, and they are known for their high-quality construction, impressive capacity, and maximum fire resistance.

One of the standout features of Liberty Safes is their impressive capacity. These safes are available in a range of sizes to suit your needs, from small personal safes to large gun safes that can hold dozens of firearms. Liberty Safes are also designed to be incredibly secure, with features like thick steel walls, reinforced doors, and locking mechanisms that are virtually impossible to pick.

Another key feature of Liberty Safes is their maximum fire resistance. These safes are built to withstand high temperatures and protect your valuables in the event of a fire. Liberty Safes use a combination of heat-activated door seals, fireboard insulation, and other fire-resistant materials to provide the ultimate protection for your possessions.

Overall, Liberty Safes are an excellent choice for anyone looking for a high-quality safe that will protect their valuables from theft and fire. Whether you are a gun owner, a jewelry collector, or simply looking to keep your important documents safe, Liberty Safes are a great investment that will give you peace of mind for years to come.

Quality and Craftsmanship

quality of American security vs liberty safes

When it comes to investing in a safe, quality and craftsmanship are two critical factors to consider. American Security Safes and Liberty Safes are both American-made and known for their quality and durability.

One significant difference between the two brands is the gauge of steel used in their construction. American Security Safes are built with 11 and 10 gauge steel, while Liberty Safes are constructed with 14 gauge steel. This difference in gauge may not seem significant, but it can make a considerable difference in the strength and durability of the safe.

In terms of craftsmanship, both brands are known for their attention to detail and high-quality workmanship. American Security Safes are built with a solid outer steel plate and incorporate the highest quality materials in a compact size. Liberty Safes, on the other hand, are built with a combination of robotic and handcrafted manufacturing processes, resulting in a high-quality product with excellent fit and finish.

Ultimately, both American Security Safes and Liberty Safes are high-quality options that provide excellent security and protection for your valuables. When choosing between the two, it's important to consider your specific needs and preferences, as well as the level of security you require.

For customers who prioritize durability and strength, American Security Safes may be the better choice due to their thicker steel construction. However, if you value a combination of craftsmanship and security, Liberty Safes may be the better option. Both brands offer a range of models with varying levels of security and features, so it's essential to compare the specific models you are interested in to find the best match for your needs.

Fire Rating and Protection

When it comes to protecting your valuable items from fire, American Security Safes and Liberty Safes are both great options. Both brands offer fire-resistant safes with varying degrees of fire protection.

American Security Safes offers fire-resistant safes that are rated to withstand high temperatures for up to 2 hours. These safes are designed to protect your valuables from fire damage and are a great choice for those who are looking for a safe that can withstand extreme temperatures.

Liberty Safes also offers fire-resistant safes that are rated to withstand high temperatures for up to 2.5 hours. These safes are designed to protect your valuables from fire damage and are a great choice for those who are looking for a safe that can withstand extreme temperatures.

Both American Security Safes and Liberty Safes use fireboard insulation to protect against fire damage. This material is designed to insulate the safe from high temperatures and prevent the heat from penetrating the safe's interior.

When choosing a fire-resistant safe, it is important to consider the fire rating and protection that the safe offers. Look for a safe that has a high fire rating and is designed to withstand extreme temperatures for an extended period of time.

For those who are looking for the ultimate in fire protection, both American Security Safes and Liberty Safes offer safes that are designed to withstand extreme temperatures for up to 2.5 hours. These safes are a great choice for those who are looking for the highest level of protection against fire damage.

Overall, both American Security Safes and Liberty Safes offer great options for those who are looking for a safe that can protect their valuable items from fire damage. When choosing a safe, be sure to consider the fire rating and protection that the safe offers to ensure that your valuables are protected in the event of a fire.

Security and Locking Mechanisms

When it comes to protecting your valuables, the security and locking mechanisms of a safe are of utmost importance. American Security Safes and Liberty Safes both offer a range of locking mechanisms that provide different levels of security.

American Security Safes use locking bolts that are made of solid steel, ensuring maximum protection against forced entry. Their safes are also designed to meet the Residential Security Container (RSC) rating, which means they can withstand an attack of up to five minutes using common hand tools. In addition, some of their safes are rated TL-15, which means they can withstand an attack of up to 15 minutes using high-powered tools.

Liberty Safes also use locking bolts, but they are made of a different material than American Security Safes. Liberty Safes use military-style locking bars that are made of hardened steel, which provides additional protection against forced entry. Their safes are also designed to meet the RSC rating, and some of their safes are rated TL-15 as well.

Both American Security Safes and Liberty Safes offer a range of locking mechanisms, including electronic, mechanical, and biometric options. Electronic locks are convenient and easy to use, while mechanical locks are reliable and do not require a power source. Biometric locks are becoming increasingly popular because they offer quick and easy access to your safe while also providing a high level of security.

Overall, both American Security Safes and Liberty Safes offer a range of locking mechanisms and security features that are designed to keep your valuables safe and secure. When choosing a safe, it's important to consider your specific needs and budget, as well as the level of security you require.

Burglary Rating and Theft Protection

As someone who values security and safety for your valuable items, it is important to understand the burglary rating and theft protection of the safes you are considering. Both American Security Safes and Liberty Safes offer a range of safes with different burglary ratings and levels of theft protection.

One important aspect to consider is the TL-rating of a safe. TL stands for "Tool-Resistant" and is a rating given by Underwriters Laboratories (UL) to safes that have been tested against various types of attacks. A TL-15 rating means that the safe can resist a burglary attempt using common hand tools for at least 15 minutes, while a TL-30 rating means the safe can resist such attempts for at least 30 minutes.

American Security Safes offers a range of safes with TL-ratings, including the TL-15 and TL-30x6. These safes are built with heavy-duty construction and incorporate the highest quality materials to provide maximum protection against burglary attempts.

Similarly, Liberty Safes also offers safes with TL-ratings, including the TL-15 and TL-30. These safes are built with thick walls and doors, reinforced with steel plates, and equipped with locking mechanisms designed to resist attacks from drills, torches, and other tools.

In addition to TL-ratings, both American Security Safes and Liberty Safes offer safes with other burglary ratings, such as the RSC (Residential Security Container) rating. This rating indicates that the safe has been tested against attacks using common hand tools for a minimum of five minutes.

When it comes to theft protection, both American Security Safes and Liberty Safes offer a range of features to keep your valuables secure. These features include advanced locking mechanisms, reinforced walls and doors, and fire-resistant materials.

Ultimately, the level of burglary rating and theft protection you choose will depend on your specific needs and budget. However, both American Security Safes and Liberty Safes offer a range of high-quality safes with varying levels of protection, so you can find the one that best fits your needs.

Warranty and Customer Reviews

As a savvy buyer, you want to make sure you are getting the best possible product for your money. That's why it's important to consider the warranty and customer reviews when choosing between American Security Safes and Liberty Safes.

Company Warranty Coverage
American Security Lifetime warranty; covers burglaries; repair or replacement provided free of charge for gun safes 55" and taller
Liberty Safe Industry-leading customer service and support; knowledgeable staff in Utah, USA

 

Both companies offer a limited lifetime warranty on their safes, which covers defects in materials and workmanship. However, American Security Safes offers an additional one-year warranty on the locking mechanism and a two-year warranty on the finish of their safes.

When it comes to customer reviews, both American Security Safes and Liberty Safes have a strong reputation for producing high-quality, reliable products. However, some customers have reported issues with the locking mechanism on Liberty Safes, while others have praised the customer service provided by American Security Safes.

For our customer avatar, a man in his 40s-60s who has an average income of $200k+ and has previously purchased weapons or important jewelry, the primary problem is security and keeping documents secure. He is worried about the fear of robbery and desires safety and security for his valuable items. He is feeling fear, worry, and stress, and believes that a man must work hard for what he wants to achieve. He wants to gain success, money, and status and wants to be rich, highly respected, and treated better. He wants to obtain a safe that protects his valuables from theft and protects hunting equipment. He wants to avoid the pain of losing documents, jewelry, guns, and other valuables.

Based on our research, both American Security Safes and Liberty Safes are reliable options for our customer avatar. However, if he is looking for additional peace of mind, he may want to consider American Security Safes for their longer warranty on the locking mechanism and finish, as well as their reputation for excellent customer service.

Price Comparison

When it comes to purchasing a gun safe, price is a major factor to consider. American Security Safes and Liberty Safes offer a wide range of gun safes at different price points. As a man with an average income of $200k+ who has purchased weapons or important jewelry, you want a gun safe that provides the best security for your valuables.

American Security Safes and Liberty Safes both offer entry-level and high-end gun safes. The entry-level gun safes from American Security Safes are priced between $700 and $1,500, while Liberty Safes' entry-level gun safes are priced between $800 and $1,500.

For high-end gun safes, American Security Safes offers models priced between $2,000 and $7,000, while Liberty Safes' high-end gun safes are priced between $2,500 and $8,000.

It is important to note that the price of a gun safe can vary based on the size, fire rating, and additional features. Both American Security Safes and Liberty Safes offer a variety of sizes and fire ratings to choose from.

As someone who desires security and safety for their items, it is important to invest in a gun safe that fits your budget and provides the necessary protection for your valuables. By comparing the prices of American Security Safes and Liberty Safes, you can find a gun safe that meets your needs and budget.

Popular Models and Comparisons

In this section, we will discuss the popular models from American Security and Liberty Safes, as well as provide a comparison between their features and offerings.

American Security Safes Models

American Security (AMSEC) offers a wide range of safes designed for maximum fire resistance and heavy-duty construction. Some popular models to consider include:

  • BF Series: These safes have a 2-hour fire rating and feature a high-security combination lock. They come in various sizes and offer an adjustable interior to accommodate your needs.

  • HS Series: This series offers a TL-15 burglary rating and a 2-hour fire rating. They are equipped with a Group 2M combination lock and massive locking bolts for added security.

  • TF Series: These are more affordable options that still provide a 30-minute fire rating and feature a digital electronic lock.

Now, let's move on to discuss popular models from Liberty Safes.

Liberty Safes Models

Liberty Safes is known for producing American-made safes with stringent quality testing. Some notable models in their lineup include:

  • American Series: These safes are made in the United States and offer a 110-minute fire rating along with thick steel locking bars. They can hold up to 50 long guns and come in various sizes.

  • Presidential Series: These high-end safes provide a 2.5-hour fire rating and feature thick 10-gauge steel construction. They also include a luxurious interior and can hold up to 39 long guns.

  • Centurion Series: This entry-level series offers a 30-minute fire rating but still includes Liberty's distinctive security features, such as military-style locking bars and a single point SureTight handle.

Now that we have covered popular models from both manufacturers, let's compare their price ranges, shipping and warranty policies.

Price and Safe Comparison

Comparing the prices between American Security and Liberty Safes, their offerings tend to be competitive. For example:

Model Series American Security Liberty Safes
High-End Series BF Series Presidential Series
Mid-Range Series NF Series American Series
Entry-Level Series TF Series Centurion Series

 

Gun Safe Models and Features

When it comes to gun safes, American Security Safes and Liberty Safes offer a wide variety of models and features that cater to the needs of different customers. As a man who values security and safety for your weapons and important jewelry, you want to make sure that you choose the right gun safe that can protect your valuables from theft.

American Security Safes offers a range of models such as the Colonial, Presidential, Presidential 50, Centurion, and Lincoln. The Colonial is a great entry-level safe that offers a good balance between price and security. The Presidential 50 is the company's top-of-the-line model and offers the highest level of security with its thicker steel walls and door. The Presidential model is also a great choice for those who want a high level of security but don't need the extra thickness of the Presidential 50.

On the other hand, Liberty Safes offers models such as the Fatboy Jr. Extreme, Franklin, and Fatboy. The Fatboy Jr. Extreme is a great choice for those who want a mid-level safe that offers good security features such as a pry-resistant door, fire protection, and a high level of storage capacity. The Franklin is a step up from the Fatboy Jr. Extreme and offers more storage capacity and a thicker steel door. The Fatboy is the company's top-of-the-line model and offers the highest level of security and storage capacity.

Both American Security Safes and Liberty Safes offer a range of features that can enhance the security and convenience of your gun safe. For example, both companies offer electronic locks that provide quick and easy access to your safe. Some models also come with fire protection, which can protect your valuables in case of a fire. Additionally, both companies offer a range of accessories such as dehumidifiers, lighting, and storage options that can help you customize your safe to your specific needs.

Overall, both American Security Safes and Liberty Safes offer a range of models and features that cater to the needs of different customers. As a man who values security and safety for your weapons and important jewelry, you can choose the right gun safe that can protect your valuables from theft by considering the models and features of both companies.

Additional Considerations

When it comes to choosing between American Security Safes and Liberty Safes, there are some additional considerations to keep in mind.

Firstly, think about your storage needs. Do you need a safe with a lot of storage space, or are you looking for something more compact? Both American Security Safes and Liberty Safes offer a range of sizes, so make sure you choose one that fits your needs.

If you have a lot of handguns, you may want to consider a safe that has specific storage for them. American Security Safes and Liberty Safes both offer handgun storage options, so take a look at what each brand has to offer and choose the one that works best for you.

If you have valuable possessions that you want to keep safe, such as jewelry or important documents, you may want to consider a safe with additional security features. Both American Security Safes and Liberty Safes offer fire and theft protection, but you may want to look into the specifics of each brand to see which one offers the level of protection you need.

Finally, think about the peace of mind you'll get from owning a high-quality safe. Knowing that your valuables are secure can help alleviate any fear or worry you may have about theft or loss. Both American Security Safes and Liberty Safes are known for their durability and reliability, so you can trust that your belongings will be safe.

As a man who has worked hard to achieve success and status, you understand the importance of protecting your valuables. You want to avoid the pain of losing important documents, jewelry, guns, or other valuable possessions. By investing in a high-quality safe from American Security Safes or Liberty Safes, you can gain the peace of mind that comes with knowing your belongings are secure.

Previous article Liberty Safes Website: The Ultimate Solution for Your Valuables Security